Ben Cowen's Macro Cycle Frameworks: Midterms, Rate Cuts and Dominance
Midterm-year lows, first cut vs last cut, the end of QT, the Sahm rule, social risk and Bitcoin dominance: what Cowen argued, what the Fed, FRED and price data show, and where each framework matched or missed.
Published 2026-11-21 · Updated 2026-11-21 · Deep Blue Alpha
Learn the basics: Liquidity, the Fed and crypto (free lesson)
Benjamin Cowen, founder of Into The Cryptoverse, uses five macro frameworks to read crypto cycles: midterm-year bear market lows, "first cut vs last cut" on Fed policy, labor-market data, social attention ("social risk"), and Bitcoin dominance with ETH/BTC. We checked each against primary data: the Fed's own FOMC records, FRED, daily Bitstamp closes and three dominance trackers.
The record is mixed. Two of three finished bear markets bottomed in a midterm year (December 15, 2018 and November 21, 2022); the third bottomed on January 14, 2015. The 2019 "top before the first cut" case matched, but BTC rose 47% in the 60 days after the September 18, 2024 first cut. Ending quantitative tightening did not lift BTC in 2019 or 2025. The ETH/BTC bottom of April 2025 was not followed by a broad altcoin season. And on September 16, 2026 the Fed raised rates for the first time since 2023, which no easing-cycle story covers.
Who Ben Cowen is, and how this review works
Benjamin Cowen founded Into The Cryptoverse in 2019 and publishes long-form market videos on YouTube. He is best known for slow, data-heavy analysis and for defending the four-year cycle in 2025 and 2026, when many analysts argued it had ended. His price-model work (log regression bands, the bull market support band) is covered in our sibling posts on logarithmic regression bands and the bull market support band. This post covers his macro and market-structure frameworks.
Three rules shape what follows. First, every Cowen view is attributed and dated, and most come from news write-ups of his videos, not from his own transcripts; we say so where it matters. Second, we do not repeat his price targets as facts. Where a past view helps test a framework, we describe it as his past stated view and then say plainly whether it matched. Third, every number on our side comes from a primary source pulled on November 20, 2026: Federal Reserve statements, FRED series, Bitstamp daily closes (UTC), and the CoinGecko, CoinMarketCap and CoinPaprika dominance readings.
One technical note on Fed dates. The Fed's open market table lists effective dates, one day after each FOMC announcement. This post uses announcement dates from the FOMC calendar and press releases.
Summary: each framework against the record
Cowen's macro frameworks vs what the data shows (as of November 20, 2026)
| Framework | His claim (as reported) | What happened | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|
| Midterm-year lows | Bear lows land in US midterm years, about a year after the top | Dec 2018 and Nov 2022 fit; the 2013–15 low came Jan 14, 2015; 2026 still open | Mixed |
| Q4 top, post-halving year | BTC tops in the fourth quarter | Daily-close high $124,728 on Oct 6, 2025 | Matched |
| First cut not instantly bullish | The start of cuts does not usually mean a bull market right away | 2019 fit; 2024 did not (+47% in 60 days) | Mixed |
| Bottom near the last cut | Markets tend to bottom close to the last cut | 2018 low came 4 days before the Fed’s last hike and pause; 2020 and 2026 lows came 134 and 202 days after the last cut | Mixed |
| QT end not automatically bullish | Ending balance-sheet runoff does not lift crypto by itself | BTC fell after the 2019 and 2025 QT endings | Matched |
| Labor data / Sahm rule | Cuts tied to rising unemployment are a warning, not a green light | Sahm hit 0.53 in July 2024, then faded; BTC doubled after | Mixed |
| Social risk | 2025 top came on apathy, not euphoria | Consistent with his reading, but the metric did not flag the top with a high reading | Mixed |
| Dominance rises in bears | BTC.D climbs through bear markets and early bulls | 2018–19 and 2023–25 fit; 2022 did not | Mixed |
| Altseason after ETH/BTC bottom | Altseason waits for ETH/BTC to bottom | ETH/BTC bottomed Apr 2025 and rose 134%; no broad altseason followed | Did not match (2025) |
Sources linked in each section below. Verdicts are Deep Blue Alpha’s reading of public data, not Cowen’s.
Framework 1: Do bear market lows land in midterm years?
His claim
Cowen’s framework holds that Bitcoin bear markets tend to bottom in US midterm election years, roughly a year after the cycle top, and that this rhythm ties crypto to the US political and business cycle rather than only to halvings. In an April 2026 interview reported by BeInCrypto (April 15, 2026), he called a bottom about a year after the top the "most likely scenario is October of 2026." In March 2026 he told Cointelegraph Magazine that 2026 was a bear market year and that Bitcoin tops in the fourth quarter.
By August 20, 2026, per a BeInCrypto report republished by Mitrade, he said he had marked July 1 as the start of an accumulation period, while still seeing a chance of one more Q4 drop like prior midterm years, in a window into late October. His past stated view in that piece included a floor near $44,000 if prior midterm years repeated. A Crypto Times headline on September 21, 2026 reported that he dropped the October bottom call after a rally; we could not open that article, so treat it as secondhand.
What history shows
Bitcoin cycle highs and lows vs US midterm elections (Bitstamp daily closes, UTC)
| Cycle | High close | Low close | Days high → low | Drawdown | Midterm election | Low vs election |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2013–15 | $1,132 (Dec 4, 2013) | $171 (Jan 14, 2015) | 406 | −84.9% | Nov 4, 2014 | 71 days after, next year |
| 2017–18 | $19,188 (Dec 16, 2017) | $3,180 (Dec 15, 2018) | 364 | −83.4% | Nov 6, 2018 | 39 days after, same year |
| 2021–22 | $67,559 (Nov 8, 2021) | $15,766 (Nov 21, 2022) | 378 | −76.7% | Nov 8, 2022 | 13 days after, same year |
| 2025–26 | $124,728 (Oct 6, 2025) | $58,526 (Jun 30, 2026)* | 267* | −53.1%* | Nov 3, 2026 | Open |
*Lowest 2026 daily close through November 20, 2026. BTC closed at $58,814 on November 20 and traded near $57,000 early on November 21 UTC, below the June 30 close. Intraday extremes differ from closes (for example $1,163 on Nov 30, 2013 and $152 on Jan 14, 2015). Source: Bitstamp OHLC API; US midterm elections fall on the first Tuesday after the first Monday in November.
Where it matched, and where it did not
Two of the three finished bear markets bottomed inside a midterm year, and both within six weeks of the election. All three took 364 to 406 days from high close to low close, which supports the "about a year after the top" part of the framework. The 2025 top also landed in the fourth quarter of the post-halving year, the timing his framework describes.
The weak spot is the first data point. The 2013–15 low is often filed under "2014," but on daily closes it came on January 14, 2015. The 2026 case is also not a clean fit so far. The lowest close of the year came on June 30, well before the late-October window, and the roughly $44,000 floor in his past stated view had not been reached as of November 20, 2026. Yet by November 20–21, BTC traded below that June close again, so whether the June low was the cycle low is unknown.
Criticism and counter-evidence
The core objection is sample size. Three finished cycles cannot separate a pattern from chance, and windows that get adjusted after the fact (a midterm year, then "about a year after the top," then a Q4 window) make the claim harder to falsify. Halvings and election dates are known years ahead, so critics argue markets can price them in ahead of time. Grayscale, Arthur Hayes and others argued in 2025–26 that the four-year rhythm had broken, as summarized in the same Cointelegraph piece. To his credit, Cowen has named his own misses, including his late-2023 view that BTC might stay below $35,000, before it broke out. For drawdown and duration data across every cycle, see our bear markets by the numbers study.
Framework 2: First cut vs last cut, and the end of QT
His claim
In a November 8, 2023 video reported by The Daily Hodl, Cowen argued that the start of rate cuts "doesn't tend to translate to an immediately bullish market," and that markets tend to bottom out close to the last rate cut. His reasoning: the Fed usually cuts because policy stayed tight too long and something is weakening. He pointed to BTC topping before the first cut in 2019. In March 2026 he told Cointelegraph that the 2025 top, like the 2019 top, came about two months before quantitative tightening (QT) ended.
What the Fed record shows
FOMC decisions and BTC on the announcement day (Bitstamp close)
| Date | FOMC action | Range after | BTC close |
|---|---|---|---|
| Dec 19, 2018 | Hike +25 bp (last of the cycle) | 2.25–2.50% | 4 days after the Dec 15 low |
| Jul 31, 2019 | First cut −25 bp; QT to end in August | 2.00–2.25% | $10,085 |
| Oct 30, 2019 | Third cut −25 bp | 1.50–1.75% | $9,160 |
| Mar 2020 | Emergency cuts (effective Mar 4 and Mar 16) | 0–0.25% | $4,842 (Mar 12 low close) |
| Sep 18, 2024 | First cut −50 bp | 4.75–5.00% | $61,757 |
| Oct 29, 2025 | Cut −25 bp; QT to end December 1 | 3.75–4.00% | $110,038 |
| Dec 10, 2025 | Cut −25 bp (last cut so far) | 3.50–3.75% | $92,036 |
| Sep 16, 2026 | Hike +25 bp, 12–0 vote | 3.75–4.00% | $76,139 |
| Oct 28, 2026 | Hold, 10–2 vote | 3.75–4.00% | $81,250 |
Sources: Jul 31, 2019, Sep 18, 2024, Oct 29, 2025, Sep 16, 2026 and Oct 28, 2026 FOMC statements; rate levels from the Fed open market table. Other cuts in 2019, 2024 and 2025 omitted for space.
Where it matched, and where it did not
2019 matched. BTC’s 2019 daily-close high was $12,921 on June 26, 35 days before the first cut, and BTC was 22% lower on the cut day. QT ended in August 2019, and BTC kept falling into the March 2020 crash.
2024 did not match. BTC fell about 12% from August 2 to September 6, 2024, then rose from $61,757 on the September 18 cut day to $91,070 by November 15, a 47% gain in under two months. On a 13-month view it doubled into the October 2025 high. A strict "first cut is not bullish" reading missed that.
2025–26 matched the QT part. On October 29, 2025 the Fed announced that runoff was to end on December 1. BTC closed at $86,291 on December 1, 2025, already below its October high, and three cuts plus the end of QT did not stop the 2026 decline. The "bottom near the last cut" part is looser: the last cut was December 10, 2025, and the lowest 2026 close came 202 days later. In 2018 the low did come four days before the Fed’s last hike and pause, which is the case he cited.
2026 adds a case no easing story covers. The Fed raised rates on September 16, 2026, its first hike since July 2023. BTC rose 12% over the next three weeks (to $85,554 on October 6), then fell 31% from there to the November 20 close while policy was on hold.
Criticism and counter-evidence
The academic record does not agree on how Fed policy moves Bitcoin at all. An August 2023 IMF working paper by Che, Copestake, Furceri and Terracciano found that Fed tightening reduces a common crypto factor through the risk-taking channel, as it does for stocks. A 2021 Bundesbank discussion paper by Sören Karau found the opposite sign for the Fed in its sample: ECB tightening lowered BTC, while a Fed tightening increased Bitcoin prices, which the author linked to emerging-market demand. When serious studies disagree on the direction, a timing rule built on cut dates deserves caution. For how tracked whales moved around FOMC days, see our whale reactions to FOMC and CPI study.
Framework 3: Unemployment, the Sahm rule and the yield curve
His claim
Cowen links rate cuts to the labor market. In his September 2024 coverage of the first cut, according to a transcript summary on rosetta.to (secondhand), he tied the cut to rising unemployment and labor-market worry. The logic of his framework: a cutting cycle that starts because unemployment is rising is a sign of weakness, not support. We could not find a dated, primary statement of a specific yield-curve rule from him, so for the yield curve we show the data only and attribute no claim.
What the data shows
Labor and yield-curve readings (FRED)
| Series | Key dates | Latest |
|---|---|---|
| Sahm rule, real time (SAHMREALTIME) | ≥0.50 in 2001–02, 2008–10, 2020–21 and Jul–Sep 2024 (peak 0.57, Aug 2024) | 0.00 (Oct 2026) |
| Unemployment rate (UNRATE) | 3.7% Jan 2024; 4.5% Nov 2025 high in this run | 4.1% (Oct 2026) |
| 10y − 2y Treasury (T10Y2Y) | Inverted Aug 27–Sep 3, 2019; Jul 6, 2022 – Sep 5, 2024 | +0.29 (Nov 20, 2026) |
| 10y − 3m Treasury (T10Y3M) | Inverted May–Oct 2019; Oct 25, 2022 – Dec 12, 2024 | +0.60 (Nov 20, 2026) |
Sources: SAHMREALTIME, UNRATE, T10Y2Y, T10Y3M, read November 20, 2026. The October 2025 value is missing in FRED’s table.
Where it matched, and where it did not
The 2024 episode is the best test. The Sahm rule crossed 0.50 with the July 2024 jobs report, released August 2, 2024. BTC closed at $61,421 that day and $54,014 on August 5, a 12% drop in three days. So the labor scare did hit crypto. But unemployment did not keep rising: the Sahm reading faded to 0.10 by mid-2025 and 0.00 by October 2026. The 10y−2y curve turned positive on September 6, 2024 with BTC at $53,955, and BTC more than doubled into the October 2025 high. In 2007 and 2019, un-inversion came shortly before recessions; in 2024 it did not.
The honest read is that labor data worked as context, explaining why the Fed cut, but it did not time crypto. The 2025–26 decline happened with the Sahm rule falling toward zero, so the "rising unemployment, then risk-off" chain was not the driver of this bear market.
Criticism and counter-evidence
The Sahm rule is a recession detector, not a market timer, and in 2024 it triggered without unemployment continuing to rise afterward. Yield-curve signals have long and variable lags. Bitcoin also has only one full recession in its trading history (2020), so any recession-based crypto rule rests on one case.
Framework 4: Social risk and attention
His claim
Cowen built a "social risk" index that combines crypto YouTube views and subscribers with X follower counts for analysts, exchanges and layer-one networks, each scaled from 0 to 1 (described in rosetta.to summaries of his videos; secondhand). On January 11, 2026 he posted that crypto YouTube views had fallen to their lowest level since January 2021, as reported by ForkLog. In March 2026, Cointelegraph summarized his view that Bitcoin topped on "apathy rather than euphoria," unlike 2017 and 2021, and that an apathy top leaves little retail demand to carry altcoins.
Where it matched, and where it did not
His reading of the 2025 top is consistent with his own data: attention stayed low while BTC set a new high. But that is the problem for the metric as a top-timing tool. In earlier cycles a high reading was the warning. In 2025 the top came with a low reading, so social risk did not flag it in advance. The "apathy top" explanation came after the top, not before, which makes it a description rather than a tested call.
Criticism and counter-evidence
Research suggests attention partly follows price. Ladislav Kristoufek’s 2013 study in Scientific Reports found that Bitcoin prices and Google and Wikipedia search interest are connected, and that the relationship is bidirectional. If rising prices pull in attention, a low attention reading may lag a move rather than lead it. Structural drift also matters: YouTube’s shift to Shorts, algorithm changes, and spot ETF buyers who never watch crypto video can all lower social numbers without lowering demand. Cowen has addressed the algorithm point directly, but platform drift is hard to rule out.
Framework 5: Bitcoin dominance and the ETH/BTC "bleed"
His claim
Cowen’s long-running view is that Bitcoin dominance rises through bear markets and early bull markets, ETH/BTC bleeds lower, and an altcoin season comes only after ETH/BTC bottoms and dominance breaks down. On February 14, 2025 he said, per The Daily Hodl, "As long as ETH/BTC goes lower, then altseason is delayed." In an October 2025 podcast reported by The Daily Hodl (October 18, 2025), he said dominance had to rise first, and that altseasons have typically followed new Ethereum highs rather than come before them.
What the data shows
Bitcoin dominance turning points (CoinMarketCap series, compiled by CoinPaprika)
| Date | BTC dominance | Context |
|---|---|---|
| Dec 16, 2017 | 56.3% | Around the 2017 BTC top |
| Jan 13, 2018 | 32.4% | Series low, ICO altcoin season |
| Sep 12, 2018 | 57.1% | Rose through the 2018 bear |
| Sep 5, 2019 | 70.9% | After the 2019 mini-top |
| Jan 2, 2021 | 71.8% | Start of the 2021 bull |
| May 18, 2021 | 39.3% | 2021 altcoin season, −32.5 pts in 136 days |
| Sep 8, 2022 | 37.7% | 2022 bear: dominance stayed low |
| Jan 18, 2024 | 49.6% | Climb under way |
| Jun 26, 2025 | 65.1% | Highest since January 2021 |
| Oct 20, 2026 | 60.1% | 2026 range roughly 57–61% |
Source: CoinPaprika, Bitcoin dominance history (own calculation on the CoinMarketCap series, October 2026).
Same day, three trackers: Bitcoin dominance on November 20, 2026
| Tracker | BTC dominance | ETH dominance |
|---|---|---|
| CoinMarketCap | 58.6% | 9.8% |
| CoinGecko | 57.7% | 9.7% |
| CoinPaprika | 56.0% | — |
Pulled from each tracker’s public global-market endpoint on November 20, 2026. The gap comes from which coins each tracker counts in total market cap, not from Bitcoin’s own value. Compare dominance only within one source.
ETH/BTC turning points (Bitstamp daily closes)
| Date | ETH/BTC | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Feb 1, 2018 | 0.1131 | Highest close in Bitstamp data (from Aug 2017) |
| Sep 6, 2019 | 0.0164 | 2019 low |
| Dec 8, 2021 | 0.0879 | 2021 high |
| Apr 21, 2025 | 0.0180 | Lowest close since early 2020 |
| Aug 24, 2025 | 0.0421 | +134% from April |
| Nov 21, 2026 | 0.0274 | −35% from the August 2025 high |
Source: Bitstamp ETH/BTC OHLC API, pulled November 20–21, 2026 UTC.
Where it matched, and where it did not
The "dominance rises" half matched twice: through the 2018 bear into 2019 (57% to 71%), and from early 2023 to June 2025 (about 39% to 65%). It did not match in 2022, when dominance stayed between about 38% and 48% through a full bear market. The ETH/BTC "bleed" view held from late 2021 to April 2025, and ETH/BTC then reached the 0.04 area in August 2025, a level news reports say he had watched for years (secondhand, Business Standard, September 2025).
The altseason half did not play out in 2025. ETH/BTC bottomed and more than doubled, but dominance never broke down the way it did in January 2018 or May 2021, and ETH/BTC gave back much of the move. His stated conditions also shifted during 2025, from "wait for ETH/BTC to bottom" in February to "dominance has to rise first" in October. A critic could fairly call that moving goalposts; a supporter might say the conditions were never all met. Our altcoin season history post maps every dominance swing by date.
Criticism and counter-evidence
Dominance is also a ratio with a moving denominator. Stablecoins also distort the ratio: they are about 10% of total market cap, and removing them lifts Bitcoin’s share by several points, so part of the 2023–25 rise reflects stablecoin growth rather than a pure Bitcoin-versus-altcoin story.
What tracked whales did this week
Macro frameworks describe the backdrop; on-chain data shows what large wallets actually did. Over the seven days to November 20, 2026, Deep Blue Alpha tracked 550 whale wallets moving ETH. In real DEX swaps, they bought $21.0M of ETH and sold $46.7M, so the trading side leaned to sellers. In exchange flow, $377.6M of ETH was withdrawn from exchanges and $328.8M deposited, a mild accumulation-side lean on transfers. The two lines point different ways, which is why we keep swaps and exchange transfers separate. The live numbers are on the ETH whale page.
Frequently asked questions
Do Bitcoin bear market lows happen in midterm years?
Two of three finished cycles: December 15, 2018 and November 21, 2022. The 2013–15 low came on January 14, 2015, 71 days after the 2014 election. The 2026 low is not settled; the lowest close through November 20 was $58,526 on June 30, and BTC traded below it again on November 20–21.
What is the "first cut vs last cut" idea?
Cowen’s view, reported in November 2023, that the first rate cut usually does not start an immediate bull market and that markets tend to bottom near the last cut. It fit 2019 and did not fit 2024, when BTC rose 47% within two months of the first cut.
Did ending QT help Bitcoin?
Not in 2019 or 2025. In both cases BTC had already topped and kept falling after the Fed ended balance-sheet runoff (August 2019; December 1, 2025).
What did the Fed do in September 2026?
It raised the federal funds range by 0.25 points to 3.75–4.00% on September 16, 2026, on a 12–0 vote, and held it there on October 28, 2026.
What does the Sahm rule say now?
It read 0.00 for October 2026, far below the 0.50 trigger last hit from July to September 2024. Unemployment was 4.1%.
Why do dominance numbers differ by site?
Each tracker counts a different set of coins in total market cap. On November 20, 2026, CoinMarketCap showed 58.6%, CoinGecko 57.7% and CoinPaprika 56.0%.
Did the 2025 ETH/BTC bottom start an altcoin season?
No broad one. ETH/BTC rose 134% from April to August 2025, but dominance stayed in the high 50s to mid 60s and ETH/BTC was 0.0274 on November 21, 2026.
Bottom line
Cowen’s macro frameworks are most useful as a checklist of questions, not as a calendar. The parts with the best record are the simplest ones: the cycle top landed in the fourth quarter of the post-halving year, bear markets lasted about a year, and ending QT or starting cuts did not by themselves rescue BTC in 2019 or 2025. The parts tied to exact dates did worse: the 2015 low sits outside the midterm year, 2024 broke the first-cut pattern, the 2025 ETH/BTC bottom brought no broad altseason, and the social-risk gauge did not flag the 2025 top.
Two things in 2026 sit outside every framework covered here: a Fed rate hike in September, and a market that made its lowest 2026 close in June and then traded back below it in November. Three finished cycles are a small sample, and the academic work on how the Fed moves crypto disagrees on the basic direction. That is not a knock on the analyst. It is a reason to check every cycle claim against dated, primary data, which is what this review tried to do.
Deep Blue Alpha tracks 20,000+ whale wallets on Ethereum and separates real DEX swaps from exchange transfers on every token page, so the macro story can be checked against what large wallets actually traded.
See what whales traded, not just what they moved
Deep Blue Alpha tracks 20,000+ whale wallets and splits real buys and sells from exchange deposits and withdrawals, live, block by block.
Open the live feed →